Commission arithmetic
Your Own Online Ordering for a Small Restaurant: When It Beats the Apps
The pitch says delivery apps are robbing you and a custom ordering page will set you free. Half of that holds up. On a delivery order the numbers are serious. On a pickup order, you might spend $2,500 to save about a dollar a ticket.
November 16, 2026 · 9 min read
The short answer
Your own ordering page makes sense when regulars would order direct anyway. On a $40 order as of November 2026, DoorDash's Plus plan takes $10 for delivery and $2.40 for pickup, while Stripe takes $1.46. Moving a delivery order to direct pickup saves real money. Moving an app pickup order to direct saves about a dollar, and neither brings new customers.
On this page
Published commissions, set against one $40 ticket
These are the rates printed on DoorDash's merchant pricing page and Uber Eats' merchant pricing page, both read in November 2026. Rates depend on your plan and sometimes your city, so your own statement outranks this table. The dollar figures are our arithmetic on a $40 subtotal, ignoring tax and tip.
| Delivery rate | On $40 | Pickup rate | On $40 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DoorDash Basic | 15% | $6.00 | 6% | $2.40 |
| DoorDash Plus | 25% | $10.00 | 6% | $2.40 |
| DoorDash Premier | 30% | $12.00 | 6% | $2.40 |
| Uber Eats Lite | 20% | $8.00 | 7% | $2.80 |
| Uber Eats Plus | 25% | $10.00 | 7% | $2.80 |
| Uber Eats Premium | 30% | $12.00 | 7% | $2.80 |
| Your own page, Stripe at 2.9% plus 30 cents | You arrange delivery | $1.46 | Same | $1.46 |
Now the fine print, which is worth an owner's five minutes. DoorDash says its 6% pickup rate requires pickup menu prices that match in-store prices. Uber Eats says its 7% pickup fee requires validated in-store pricing, otherwise 10%. It also lists lower rates in select cities, an added 5% on Uber One orders on its Plus plan, and a separate 15% fee for self-delivery. Both have intro offers and conditional rebates. Read the current page and your own agreement, because terms like these move.
Where direct ordering pays, and where it is a hobby
Take the two moves separately. Say a regular who has been paying for app delivery on DoorDash Plus now walks over and picks up an order placed on your own site. You keep $8.54 more on that $40 ticket. Now say a regular who already picks up through the app switches to your page. You keep 94 cents more. Those are our figures from the table above. The same restaurant, same food, wildly different payoff.
| Saved per $40 order | Orders to repay a $2,500 store | Orders a month to cover hosting at $55, our starting rate | |
|---|---|---|---|
| App delivery on Plus becomes direct pickup | $8.54 | About 293 | About 7 |
| App delivery on Basic becomes direct pickup | $4.54 | About 551 | About 13 |
| App pickup on Uber Eats becomes direct pickup | $1.34 | About 1,866 | About 42 |
| App pickup on DoorDash becomes direct pickup | $0.94 | About 2,660 | About 59 |
Spending $2,500 to save 94 cents a ticket is a hobby with a domain name.
If you are running your own drivers, costs change entirely, and you must add wages, insurance and the fact that one driver can only be in one place. We will not guess at those. For a business with fewer than 10 people, running delivery in-house is usually the expensive answer unless you already have someone on the road. And the apps deliver one thing no ordering page can: people who have never heard of you. Treat them as a marketing cost, then decide what you would pay for that customer.

Read your own statement before you read our sales page
No published rate tells you what you actually pay. The statement will, and it takes about half an hour with a highlighter. If you are on a plan we did not list, or your city has its own rate, this is the number that matters.
- 1
Pull one full month from each app
Use a normal month. Avoid the one with the festival in it.
- 2
Add up order subtotals
That is your food sales through that app, before tax and tip.
- 3
Add up everything taken out
Commission, marketing, promotions you agreed to, refunds and adjustments, and any processing fees.
- 4
Divide the second number by the first
That is your real rate. Write it on the wall above the printer.
- 5
Sort orders by delivery and pickup
Then use the table above with your own rate, not ours, and your own average ticket.
- 6
Estimate how many are regulars
Apps may not hand you this. Ask the person bagging orders which names they know. It is a rough number, and it beats none at all.
Regulars are the only orders a direct page can realistically move. If nine in ten of your app orders come from strangers, an ordering page will mostly sit there, looking fine. Fix being found first: the Google Maps page for small businesses and the free map pack audit are better uses of the next dollar.
Cheaper doors to try before you hire anybody
Your register may already do it
Many point-of-sale systems include online ordering, so check yours first. Square's fees page lists online cards at 3.3% plus 30 cents on Square Free, as of November 2026, which is $1.62 on $40.
The apps sell direct ordering too
DoorDash's pricing page says orders through Online Ordering by DoorDash carry no commission, only a payment processing fee, as of November 2026. Read those terms and see who keeps the customer's data.
The telephone
Old and free. If your menu is short and your regulars have your number, a good site with the menu on an actual page, not a blurry PDF, may do almost all the work.
A standard online store
Pickup-only with a small menu can run on a hosted cart. Test your hardest order, the one with three modifiers and a substitution, before committing.
What a custom ordering page has to do on a Friday at 6
Suppose you have done the math and want your own. Here is the part that gets skipped in the demo. A store sells a boxed item from a shelf. A kitchen sells something that does not exist yet, from a stock level that changes during service, to someone who wants no onions. These are the screens and the data it has to handle, and you should see each one work before you pay.
- A menu with modifiers. Sizes, sides, no onions, extra sauce, each with a price, without a developer for each change.
- An off switch for one item. Out of brisket at 6:40. You or the cook turn it off from a phone in five seconds, or the next order is an apology.
- Kitchen hours and a pause button. Orders must stop before close, and you must be able to pause when the line is out the door.
- Pickup times the kitchen can hit. Ten orders cannot all be ready at 6:15. Slots or a stated wait, one or the other.
- A ticket the kitchen will actually see. A tablet, a printer or your point-of-sale system. An email is not a ticket. An integration with your register from $575, depending on complexity, goes live the same day if your system offers an API.
- Tax, tips and refunds. Tax set right for your location, a tip line if you want one, and a refund you can issue while holding a tray. Stripe keeps its original fee on refunds, so decide in advance when a remake beats a refund.
What would it cost? Online stores start at $2,500, and an ordering feature added to a site you already have can start from $575, depending on complexity. Your quote depends on the list above, especially the kitchen connection. 0% financing turns $2,500 into $625 down and $156.25 a month for 12 months. At $8.54 saved per switched order, that monthly payment is about 19 orders, which is one more way to test the idea.
Getting regulars to change one small habit
Your ordering page will not fill itself, and nobody can promise you it will. The audience is people already eating your food, so the marketing is cheap and short: a card in the bag, a line on the receipt, the link on your Google Business Profile if your listing offers the option, and a word from whoever hands over the order. Check any app's terms before you put flyers in its bags. We are not lawyers, so take questions about promotions and review rules to your own attorney.
Worth saying to a regular
- Ordering direct means more of your money stays here
- It is ready when we say it is, and you skip the line
- If something is wrong, you talk to us
- Here is the link, and here is how long a usual order takes
Not worth doing
- Offering a free dessert for a Google review, which Google's policy does not allow
- Paying for an expensive launch before ten regulars have tried it
- Promising delivery you cannot staff on a Friday
- Putting up a page and telling no one
When people ask a phone or an AI assistant where to eat, your name, hours and menu need to be right. We cover that in the voice search guide for restaurants and the AI search page for restaurants. The broader overview of small-store builds is there if ordering is only part of what you need, and (210) 346-0848 is there if you want someone to check your arithmetic before you sign.
Questions owner-operators ask
As of November 2026, DoorDash's merchant page lists 15%, 25% and 30% delivery commission by plan and 6% for pickup. Uber Eats lists 20%, 25% and 30% marketplace fees and a 7% pickup fee, with conditions and lower rates in select cities. Your own statement is the number that counts, since terms vary by plan, city and promotion.
Mostly no, and we would not promise otherwise. A direct page usually serves people who already know you, which is why its value rests on how many of your app orders come from regulars. Apps show you to strangers. If you need new customers, work on local search and your Google listing, and keep the apps running.
Usually not on its own. At published November 2026 rates, a $40 pickup order costs $2.40 on DoorDash and $2.80 on Uber Eats, against $1.46 through Stripe. That saves about 94 cents to $1.34 per order, by our arithmetic. A build pays back far faster on orders that would otherwise be app delivery.
Rarely as a first step. Check your point-of-sale system's ordering tool and the commission-free direct options the apps offer. Custom earns its keep when your menu, kitchen setup or volume makes those awkward. Do your statement math first. If switched delivery orders will not repay the build within a time you can stomach, stay put.
Online stores start at $2,500, and features added to an existing site can start at $575, depending on complexity. Hosting and maintenance starts at $55 a month, and card fees go to your processor. The kitchen connection usually drives the quote. We will say so if your register's built-in tool is a better purchase.
Keep reading
- Per-order mathWhat a Small Online Store Costs to Build, and What Each Order KeepsHow much a small online store costs to build and run: five starting points, real card fees, shipping, and the math on one made-up $48 order.
- Google Maps, one ownerHow to Get Found on Google Maps When You Are the Whole CompanyHow a small business gets found on Google Maps: what relevance, distance and prominence mean for one owner, plus a free test you can run from your truck.
- One owner, one phoneWeb Design for One-Person Businesses: What You Need and What to RefuseWebsite design for one-person businesses: the short page list, what to refuse to pay for, and fixed prices from $1,500, or when a builder plan is better.
- The build sideSmall Business Website Development: Who Holds the Keys When the Builder LeavesWebsite development for independent contractors: who owns the code, domain and accounts, what custom means at $1,500, and what you must maintain yourself.
- Probably not. Sometimes yes.iOS App Development for Small Businesses: When an iPhone App Earns Its KeepWhen an iPhone app makes sense for a very small company, what from $3,750 buys, Apple's fees and rules as of 2026, and what to try before you build.
- Two stores, one budgetMobile App Development for Small Business: iPhone, Android or a Web App FirstiPhone and Android apps for a small business: web app from $575, native from $3,750, Google Play and Apple fees as of 2026, and what to build first.
- Everything in MicrobusinessSee the section
From the Insights desk
- The Most Expensive Rebrand in Email Is Two Letters LongA brand I actually buy from swapped its newsletter address for something friendlier, and the mail went straight to junk. You don't own your place in the inbox — you rent it, and the deposit is your sending history. What that costs, and how to move without losing it.
- The Seven Levels of TikTok Advertising (and Why Your Commercial Is Not One of Them)Most businesses upload their TV commercial to TikTok and watch it get scrolled past. The seven levels of TikTok advertising, from the three-second hook and Spark Ads to tracking, Smart+ and a steady supply of new creative.
Send us one month of app statements
Tell us your plan, your average ticket and what your register is. A person at DataCram replies with the math on your numbers, and a plain answer on whether a direct page would ever pay for itself.
Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)
Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.