Stay, fix or go

Migrating a Small Business Website Away From WordPress, and the Good Reasons to Stay

Nobody at your business chose WordPress as a philosophy. Somebody installed it in 2017, and now it is yours, along with 31 plugins you have never met. Before you pay to move anywhere, find out whether the platform is really the problem.

November 17, 2026 · 9 min read

acmebakery.com · a phone call about the site
The first question to ask
Stay, fix or go, for a fictional bakery
My WordPress site broke again. Should I move off it?
What does it need to do, and how many plugins load on the home page?
Hours, a menu, a contact form. There are 31 plugins.
Then the platform may not be the problem. Remove what you do not use, test the form, and price a simple site only if it keeps breaking.
Illustrative: a sample exchange about a fictional bakery

The short answer

Move a small business website off WordPress when upkeep costs more than it returns: repeat repairs, plugin sprawl and nobody watching. Stay if it runs well and someone reachable looks after it. A move means exporting content, rebuilding templates and redirecting every changed address. DataCram's fixed prices run by page count, from $1,500 for up to 10 pages.

On this page
  1. WordPress is not the villain, and we sell the alternative
  2. What WordPress asks of a one-person IT department
  3. Who should stay, who should tune and who should go
  4. Where you could actually go, including the cheap exit
  5. How the move actually works, step by step
  6. What the move costs, and what you give up by moving

WordPress is not the villain, and we sell the alternative

Start with the plain fact: W3Techs reports, as of November 2026, that WordPress runs 39.4% of all websites, and 58.2% of sites whose content management system it can identify. That many owners are not all confused. WordPress is free to install. Almost any freelancer can work on it. If you need a strange feature at 10 p.m., somebody has probably written a plugin. A well-run WordPress site is a perfectly good site.

We have an interest here, and you should weigh what follows accordingly. We build sites on Athena CMS, our own system, and repair WordPress for a fixed fee as well, so we are paid either way. Our comparison at Athena against WordPress makes our case at length. This page asks something smaller: for a business with one owner and no IT person, is the upkeep still worth it?

Before anything else, run the free leave or stay check. It reads your theme, your builder and the plugins that load on your home page, and returns a verdict of keep it, fix it or move. You verify an email once, and it takes a few minutes. It may save you this whole conversation.

What WordPress asks of a one-person IT department

The software is free in the way a puppy is free. Patchstack, a company that sells WordPress security, reports in a page updated February 25, 2026 that 11,334 new vulnerabilities were found in the WordPress ecosystem in 2025, up 42% from 2024. Of those, 91% were in plugins and 9% in themes, and 6 were reported in WordPress core. It also reports that 46% had no patch by the time of disclosure. Discount for the seller if you like. The shape is the point: the core is not where the trouble lives. It lives in the add-ons, and they are the reason most owners picked WordPress.

For a company with a staff, that is one person's Tuesday. For you, it means updates that can break the layout, a plugin whose author has moved on, and a monthly chore that loses every time to a customer with a leak. Our upkeep cost page puts hours on it, and why WordPress gets heavy explains the other complaint. The real question is who does this work, not whether the software is good.

Glowing cyan lines branching from a dense tangled knot into one clean line on a deep blue and violet field with a thin data grid
The migration is mostly an inventory: what you have, what you keep and where each page goes.

Who should stay, who should tune and who should go

A decision table for small business WordPress sites
Our adviceWhy
Runs fine, few plugins, someone reachable keeps it updatedStay. Do not let anyone talk you out of itMoving costs money, and it solves nothing here
Slow, but otherwise fineTune firstAn evening's work or a $399 speed fix may do it
One bad update, one hack, one recoveryRepair, then get it watched$149 to $399 to fix, and from $55 a month if you want it looked after
A large blog, and an editor who knows WordPress wellProbably stayYour workflow has real value. A move has to beat it
A store with many extensions and years of order dataCareful study firstA move is a large job. See WooCommerce to Next.js
Page builder, dozens of plugins, repeat breakage, nobody who wants to own itPrice a moveTuning buys time, and each repair adds up. See repair or replace
Three or four simple pages and a phone numberMove, maybe not to usA builder plan could be all you need
If you cannot name what your plugins do, you do not have a platform problem yet. You have an inventory problem.

Where you could actually go, including the cheap exit

Leaving WordPress does not mean hiring us. For the long view, our five-year count in dollars and Saturdays puts WordPress and Next.js on the same calendar, upkeep included. Here are the honest destinations, with other companies' prices as of November 2026. On each one, ask two questions before you sign: can I take my content with me if I leave, and who fixes it on a Tuesday?

A hosted builder

Squarespace lists Basic at $25 a month billed monthly or $19 billed annually, and Core at $39 or $29, with a 2% store fee on Basic. Wix lists a Free plan and paid plans, with prices varying by location. No plugins to patch. For a simple site, this is often the right, cheap answer, and our builder comparison is fair to them.

A hosted store

If you mainly sell products, Shopify's plans start with Basic at $39 a month billed monthly or $29 billed yearly. Read Shopify against a custom store for the fee math. A one-person store owner could do worse.

A custom site on Next.js with Athena CMS

That is our product. Plain fields for what you actually change, far fewer parts that need patching, and fixed pricing by page count. The cost is that it needs a developer for structural changes, and you cannot install a plugin at 10 p.m.

Better-run WordPress

The option nobody markets, since it changes nothing but the habits. Fewer plugins, good hosting, updates on a schedule. Often the best value on this list, and we will happily look after it.

How the move actually works, step by step

Your words are the easy part. WordPress's own documentation, last updated June 8, 2024, says its export tool produces an XML file with posts, pages, custom post types, comments, custom fields, categories, tags, custom taxonomies and users. Note what that list does not name: your theme, your page builder's layouts, your plugin settings. Those do not travel. They get rebuilt, or rethought, which is often the point of moving.

  1. 1

    Write down every address on the site

    Pull them from your sitemap and Search Console. This list is the single most valuable document in the project, and owners skip it most often.

  2. 2

    Mark what earns its keep

    Pages that get visits or links stay, or get a new home. Pages nobody has read since the 2015 holiday sale can go, on purpose, rather than by accident.

  3. 3

    Export the content and take a full backup

    Files and database, stored off the server. Keep it for good after launch, since the old site's copy is hard to get later.

  4. 4

    Rebuild the structure, and move the content over

    This is where most of the money goes, and it applies to any destination. Clean up as you go, and rewrite the pages that never worked.

  5. 5

    Map old addresses to new ones with permanent redirects

    Redirect details are here. Google's guidance is covered below.

  6. 6

    Rebuild forms and test them before launch

    Every one, and the booking link as well. Test them again after launch, once the mail is coming from a new server.

  7. 7

    Move DNS last, and leave email alone

    Screenshot your records first. Careless DNS work is how business email stops after a move.

  8. 8

    Watch Search Console for a few weeks

    Fix the missing pages it reports. Keep the old redirects in place long after you have stopped thinking about them.

On that watching: Google Search Central, read in November 2026, says permanent redirects do not cause a loss in PageRank, to keep them generally at least a year, and to expect temporary fluctuation during a move. A small to medium site can take a few weeks for most pages to move. Our fuller treatment is moving off WordPress without losing SEO. No one can guarantee your rankings after a move, and anyone who does is not reading Google's page.

What the move costs, and what you give up by moving

A move to a custom site with us is priced like any new site, by page count: up to 10 pages $1,500; 11 to 20 pages $2,250; 21 to 50 pages $3,750; 51 to 70 pages $5,750. That includes SEO, design, content writing, Athena CMS, lead form capture, online booking, one custom API integration and 1 year of support. We recommend the largest package for organic reach because of its page depth, though a one-person shop often does not need it. Through website financing, $1,500 is $375 down and $93.75 a month at 0%. Our page on the move's cost has more.

What you give up

  • A vast plugin store, and any feature you can add yourself at night
  • A huge pool of people who can work on your site
  • An editor you may already know
  • Money and hours, up front, in a season you may not have them

What you stop doing

  • Weekly plugin updates, and hoping nothing broke
  • Paying for plugin licenses you cannot remember buying
  • Watching a page builder load on every page
  • Wondering which of 31 things is responsible

Over the long run, WordPress's five-year cost lays out the comparison, and switching from WordPress to Athena shows the editor. If you stay, the maintenance section will help you keep it healthy. Either way, the rest of our guide for businesses with fewer than 10 employees applies.

Questions owner-operators ask

Yes, when someone is actually looking after it. It is free to install and widely supported, and W3Techs reports it on 39.4% of all websites. The weakness is upkeep, particularly plugins. If you have no one to do updates and repairs, and you keep paying for emergencies, a hosted builder or a custom site might suit you better. If it is working, keep it.

Not your words, if the move is done carefully. WordPress's export tool covers posts, pages, comments, custom fields, categories, tags and users, in an XML file. Your theme, your builder layouts and your plugin settings do not come across, and images need separate attention. Take a full backup before anyone starts, and keep it after launch. That backup is your insurance if something is missed.

It depends mostly on page count and on how much you want rewritten, so we quote it after looking. On Google's side, its documentation says a small to medium site can take a few weeks for most pages to move in search after the change. See our timeline notes. A store with years of order history takes longer than a ten-page service site.

Yes, in most destinations. A builder gives you a drag and drop editor. On our sites, Athena CMS gives you plain fields for services, prices, hours, posts and more, so you cannot break the layout by accident. The trade is that structural changes come to a developer. If you love fiddling with layouts yourself, a builder will suit you better.

Not necessarily. Most reported problems, according to Patchstack, are in plugins rather than in core. Fewer plugins, regular updates, tested backups and good hosting reduce the risk a good deal, though nothing removes it. If your site is hacked now, cleaning it comes first, at $349 with our malware cleanup. Decide about the platform afterward, when you are calm.

You can. It is a real option called a headless setup, and it keeps the familiar editor while a separate system draws the pages. It also keeps WordPress and adds another thing to look after, which is hardly the goal for a one-person business. It suits a team with a heavy editing habit. See keeping WordPress as your editor for how it works.

Keep reading

Free · No obligation

Ask us whether you should leave, and expect a real answer

Send the address and what keeps going wrong. A person at DataCram replies with stay, fix or go, gives you the fixed price if it is go, and tells you if a cheaper builder fits better.

Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)

Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.

CallGet a quote