Run the numbers first
Should You Repair or Replace Your Website? A Decision Table With the Dollars Filled In
One person says fix it. Another says it cannot be saved, and that person sells new websites. We also sell new websites, so check our math. Here are both prices, a 24-month comparison, and the point where we would stop patching.
November 15, 2026 · 8 min read
The short answer
Repair your website when one fix under $400 solves the problem and you control and can edit the site. Consider replacing it when repairs in a year pass about $750, half of a new site, by our rule of thumb, or when the software cannot be updated. A new DataCram site of up to 10 pages costs $1,500.
On this page
Our conflict of interest, disclosed in the first paragraph
We earn more when you replace. A WordPress repair brings us $149 to $399. A new website brings at least $1,500. You should know that going in, and you should expect the same bias from anyone else with a price list. So this page gives you the numbers and a table you can check, and it will recommend the cheaper path where the cheaper path is right. That happens more often than our sales numbers would like.
A sister page, when to replace a website, covers the warning signs and the tests you can run. This one assumes you have a broken or aging site and a decision to make this month, and it takes up only the money. Every figure from us below is a published price. Your own numbers will differ, so bring them.
| Repair (WordPress, fixed) | Replace (new site, fixed by page count) | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | $149, one error | $1,500, up to 10 pages |
| Middle | $199, a conflict. $249, site down | $2,250, 11 to 20 pages |
| Upper | $349, malware. $399, speed | $3,750, 21 to 50 pages. $5,750, 51 to 70 pages |
| What is included | The fix, and a refund if we cannot fix it | SEO, design, content writing, Athena CMS, lead form capture, online booking, one custom API integration, 1 year of support |
| Payment | Paid up front | In full, or 0% with 25% down, up to 12 months |
The decision table, one situation per row
Find your situation. Where two rows apply, the more serious one wins. The $750 line is our own rule of thumb, half the price of the entry site, and it has no authority beyond being a sensible place to stop and think. A site that costs you more than $750 in repairs inside 12 months is telling you something.
| Repair cost | Replacement cost | Our call | |
|---|---|---|---|
| One error, and the site otherwise earns its keep | $149 | $1,500 | Repair. Not close |
| An update broke the layout | $199 | $1,500 | Repair, then remove what caused it |
| Site went down once this year | $249 | $1,500 | Repair, and find out why |
| Slow, otherwise fine, and you'll keep it 2 more years | $399 | $1,500 | Try the free evening's work first, then repair |
| Hacked once | $349 | $1,500 | Repair and add monitoring from $55 a month |
| Hacked twice in a year | $698 | $1,500 | Close to the line. Ask why, before paying a third time |
| Three different repairs in a year | $597 to $997, by our sums | $1,500 | Past or near the line. Price a replacement |
| Software too old to update | A patch that won't last | $1,500 and up | Replace, or budget for it this year |
| You cannot edit it without paying someone | Not a repair issue | $1,500 and up | Replace, or ask first whether an editor can be added |
| Dated look, working phone | $0 | $1,500 and up | Do nothing. Spend it elsewhere |
| Never produced a single call | Unknown | Unknown | Neither yet. Run the seven lead checks |
| The domain or host is not in your name | Unknown | Unknown | Neither yet. Get your keys first |

Twenty-four months, worked out in actual dollars
Say a one-person landscaping business in Tyler, invented for this example, has an old WordPress site that is slow and has been hacked once. It stays on either way, with our plan starting at $55 a month, because leaving it unwatched is how it got hacked. Repair prices are ours. Whether those two repairs would be the only ones in two years is the guess, so change it if you like.
| Keep and repair | Replace | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed fix | $399 | $0 |
| Malware cleanup | $349 | $0 |
| New site, up to 10 pages | $0 | $1,500 |
| Hosting and maintenance, 24 months | $1,320 | $1,320 |
| Total | $2,068 | $2,820 |
Replacing costs $752 more in this example. Now ask what that $752 buys. New content written for the jobs you want. Online booking. An editor you can use without breaking anything. One custom API integration. A site with far fewer moving parts. If those would earn more than $752 for you in two years, replacing is the better buy. If your old site already does the job and your customers arrive by referral, keep the $752. It is your money, and it will buy a lot of diesel.
If cash decides it, a $1,500 site through 0% website financing is $375 down and $93.75 a month for 12 months, or $1,500 in total. Redesigns are covered too, at website redesign financing. One catch: financed sites stay on our platform for the length of the plan. A one-person shop rarely needs the 51 to 70 page package at $5,750. We recommend it for organic reach because of page depth, and that does not mean it fits you. Our budget notes can help you size it.
Costs that never appear on either invoice
What repairing hides
- Your hours on the phone, finding logins, and explaining the same site to a new person
- Downtime, and what you miss during it
- A form that broke in the same event and went unnoticed
- The next plugin vulnerability on software you never chose
What replacing hides
- Your hours gathering photos, reviewing drafts and answering questions, at 10 p.m.
- Redirects. Miss them and old addresses die, along with whatever they had earned
- A temporary wobble in search while Google sorts out the move
- Learning a new editor, and retesting email and forms after launch
About that wobble: Google Search Central, read in November 2026, tells site owners to expect temporary ranking fluctuation during a move, says a small to medium site can take a few weeks for most pages to move, and advises keeping redirects generally at least a year. It also says permanent redirects do not cause a loss in PageRank. Nobody can guarantee where you land afterward. That applies to us, and to whoever is telling you a redesign will lift your rankings.
Four questions that overrule the arithmetic
Sometimes the dollars point one way and the facts point the other. These four come before the spreadsheet, and any one of them can end the discussion.
- 1
Do you control the domain and the accounts?
If not, neither path is safe yet. Spending money on a site someone else can switch off is a poor investment at any price. Who holds what comes first.
- 2
Can the software still be updated?
A site stuck on an old version of its software, because updating breaks a theme no one supports, can be patched but not really fixed. Each repair buys months.
- 3
Can you, personally, change your prices on a Tuesday?
If every edit costs a developer's invoice, the site's cost never stops. A custom build should never work that way, and our guide to owner editing on Next.js shows which changes stay yours. On the other hand, a site you rarely change makes this question irrelevant.
- 4
Has it ever brought in work?
If it has, respect that before you tear it down. If it never has, then a repair restores a thing with no record of doing anything, and a replacement might just repeat it. Find out why first.
How to check us before you sign anything
If we tell you to replace, make us earn it. Ask which specific thing cannot be repaired, and why, in writing. Run the free website health check and the WordPress leave or stay check, and see if they agree. Ask another shop for a repair quote, and mention the replacement quote. A real answer names files, versions and costs. A sales answer says the site is "dated."
- Keeping WordPress? The maintenance section covers looking after it, and the cost page tests whether you need a plan at all.
- Leaving WordPress? A fair look at moving off it includes the good reasons to stay.
- Not on WordPress? Our repair prices do not apply, and how to triage a broken site tells you what to try first.
- Still deciding? Call (210) 346-0848. We will look at it and give you a straight recommendation, including "keep it." The rest of our small business guide stays useful either way.
Questions owner-operators ask
Our rule of thumb is about $750 in repairs within 12 months, half the price of a new 10-page site with us. That is our judgment, not a law of nature. A site you love at $900 might still beat a replacement, and a site you can't edit might not be worth $200. Use the line to force the conversation, then look at whether the problems are likely to repeat.
Almost always cheaper to fix once, sometimes more expensive to fix repeatedly. A single repair costs $149 to $399 with us, against $1,500 for a new site of up to 10 pages. The comparison changes after three or more repairs, or when the site cannot do what you need. Add your own hours on both sides, because that is the cost neither invoice shows.
You might see temporary movement. Google says to expect temporary fluctuation during a move, and it says permanent redirects do not cause a loss in PageRank. Most lasting damage comes from skipped redirects and deleted content that was earning traffic. Keep the addresses that work, redirect the ones that change, and save a list of your old pages before anyone starts. Nobody can guarantee the result.
Ask for the specific reason in writing: which software, which version, what cannot be updated, and what a repair would cost. Then get a second opinion from someone who is not quoting the replacement. If the answer is mainly about looks, it is a preference and not a diagnosis. If the answer names unsupported software or unrecoverable damage, take it seriously.
Sometimes. You can rewrite service pages one at a time, or add online booking from $575, depending on complexity, while the old site stays up. A change of platform, however, is usually one move. A patch-and-replace approach is fair if money is tight: fix what stops the phone from ringing today, and schedule the larger job for your slow season.
Keep reading
- Keep it, fix it or start overWhen Should a Small Business Replace Its Website? Later Than the Salesperson SaysWhen should a small business replace its website? Eight tests you can run this week, the reasons to keep what you have, and what to protect if you move.
- Nobody was lookingWebsite Maintenance for One-Person Businesses: Who Looks After the Site When You CannotSmall business website care from $55 a month: hosting, updates, backups and small edits, what quietly fails when nobody looks, and when not to pay us.
- One owner, one phoneWeb Design for One-Person Businesses: What You Need and What to RefuseWebsite design for one-person businesses: the short page list, what to refuse to pay for, and fixed prices from $1,500, or when a builder plan is better.
- The build sideSmall Business Website Development: Who Holds the Keys When the Builder LeavesWebsite development for independent contractors: who owns the code, domain and accounts, what custom means at $1,500, and what you must maintain yourself.
- Probably not. Sometimes yes.iOS App Development for Small Businesses: When an iPhone App Earns Its KeepWhen an iPhone app makes sense for a very small company, what from $3,750 buys, Apple's fees and rules as of 2026, and what to try before you build.
- Two stores, one budgetMobile App Development for Small Business: iPhone, Android or a Web App FirstiPhone and Android apps for a small business: web app from $575, native from $3,750, Google Play and Apple fees as of 2026, and what to build first.
- Everything in MicrobusinessSee the section
From the Insights desk
- GEO, AEO, LLMO: Mostly SEO With a New InvoiceThree acronyms arrive with the confidence of a new discipline and the pricing of one. Some of it is real. Most is SEO renamed — because retrieval still runs on an index of the web. How to tell which line items are which.
- GoDaddy Hired Walton Goggins to Sell You a Website. The White Lotus Already Showed You How That Ends.GoDaddy put The White Lotus star Walton Goggins in front of Airo, its 'type a sentence, get a website' AI builder. But a builder hands you a beautiful front desk and nothing working behind it. Why a DIY AI site won't get you found, convert, or compete — and what actually does.
Get a recommendation from someone willing to say keep it
Send your site and what has gone wrong this year. A person at DataCram replies with repair or replace and the dollars behind it, and tells you if the right answer is to do nothing.
Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)
Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.