Per-order math

What a Small Online Store Costs to Build, and What Each Order Keeps

The quote is the number everybody asks about, and it is rarely the number that decides things. A $48 order can leave you $21 or leave you nothing. Here is what a small store costs to open, and how to find out what one sale actually keeps.

November 10, 2026 · 8 min read

acmecandleco.com · one order
Where a $48 order goes
The quote was never the expensive part
Per order
Customer pays, free shipping$48.00
Product and laborminus $14.00
Box and fillerminus $2.50
Shipping labelminus $9.00
Card fee, 2.9% plus 30 centsminus $1.69
Left for rent, ads, software and you$20.81
Illustrative: a sample order for a fictional candle maker

The short answer

A small online store can start with a Stripe payment link, where you pay only per sale, or cost $29 to $39 a month on Shopify Basic as of November 2026. A custom build through DataCram starts at $2,500. The number that decides things is what each order keeps after product, packing, shipping and card fees near 3% plus 30 cents.

On this page
  1. Five ways in, from one evening to a real build
  2. One made-up order, followed all the way to the bank
  3. Shipping is where small margins quietly go missing
  4. Small percentages that turn into real money by December
  5. The first-year bill, once the boring tools show up
  6. Run these numbers before you pay anyone, us included

Five ways in, from one evening to a real build

Forty-nine dollars buys you a logo. Nobody has yet found the package that also buys customers. Store pricing has the same problem: the entry price is easy to compare and tells you little. Start with the five doors below, and take the cheapest one your product will actually fit through.

Starting points for a very small store, list prices as of November 2026
To startMonthlyOnline card feeFits when
Stripe payment linkAn eveningPer-sale fees only, on the site you have2.9% plus 30 centsFew products, buyers who already know you
Square Free planAn evening or twoPer-sale fees3.3% plus 30 centsYou already take cards in person
Squarespace CoreA weekend$39, or $29 billed annuallyProcessor's fee, no 2% store fee on CoreA small catalog with a real website around it
Shopify BasicA weekend or two$39, or $29 billed yearly2.9% plus 30 cents with Shopify PaymentsSelling is the main job of the site
DataCram custom storeFrom $2,500From $55 for hosting and maintenance2.9% plus 30 cents through StripeThe product has rules a cart cannot hold

If the last two rows are your real choice, the comparison of Shopify and a custom store has the five-year totals. If you were expecting a line for a store your nephew builds free before moving to Denver, that one has no monthly fee. It does have a monthly mystery. Whatever you choose, keep the domain in your own name, and take the wider budget view for a small site before you sign anything.

One made-up order, followed all the way to the bank

Say a candle maker in Waco, invented for this example, sells a $48 gift set with free shipping. The product and packing figures below are hers, and also fiction. Replace them with your own. The card fee is real: Stripe's standard US rate as of November 2026, on a domestic card, comes to $1.69 on $48.

Where a made-up $48 order goes
AmountNote
Customer pays$48.00Free shipping, tax left out for simplicity
Wax, wicks, jars, labor to pourminus $14.00Invented
Box, filler, tape, thank-you cardminus $2.50Invented
Shipping labelminus $9.00Invented: weigh yours and get a real carrier quote
Card fee, 2.9% plus 30 centsminus $1.69Stripe, as of November 2026
Left to pay for everything else$20.81Rent, ads, software, you

Now you can price the platform in orders rather than dollars. At $20.81 an order, Shopify Basic at $29 takes two orders a month. Our hosting, at its $55 starting rate, takes three. A financed $2,500 store, at $156.25 a month for 12 months after $625 down, plus hosting, is $211.25, which takes 11 orders a month in the first year. All of that is our arithmetic on an invented order. It also assumes you do not pay yourself. Packing at 15 minutes an order, 40 orders is 10 hours of your month.

Warm shallow-focus photo of hands weighing a small parcel on a kitchen scale beside tape, a phone and a stack of plain boxes, no faces
The price of an order gets decided here, at the scale, long before anyone reads a pricing page.

Shipping is where small margins quietly go missing

We will not quote carrier rates, because they depend on weight, size, distance and whatever account you hold. What we can tell you is how to stop guessing. Weigh your three most common orders in their boxes. Get a quote for each to your farthest likely customer. Use that number, not the average, when you decide on free shipping.

  • Free shipping is a price cut. In the example above it costs $9 out of $48. Offering it may sell more, but put it in your math as what it is.
  • A flat rate shifts the risk. You lose on long trips and win on short ones. That works if you know your mix, so check it against the last 50 orders.
  • A minimum order can pay for itself. Free shipping over a set dollar amount only helps if the second item costs little to add to the box.
  • Big, fragile or heavy goods need a closer look. A local-pickup option can rescue a product no carrier will carry cheaply. If that sounds like your business, read about selling without much stock on hand.
  • Labels take time as well as money. Once you pass a few orders a day, the case for automating labels and stock updates gets stronger.

Small percentages that turn into real money by December

The same $48 sale costs different amounts depending on how the money moves, and these are the rates as of November 2026. PayPal's page, updated November 4, 2026, lists 3.49% plus 49 cents for PayPal Checkout, which comes to $2.17. Square's Free plan takes $1.88 online. Stripe takes $1.69. Pay for an outside processor on Shopify Basic and Shopify adds 2%, about 96 cents, on top of the processor's own fee.

A refund costs more than the refund

Stripe says its processing fees from the original payment are not returned. So a refunded $48 order is still down $1.69, plus the $9 label, plus packing if the goods cannot be resold.

A dispute costs $15 before you argue

Stripe charges $15 per dispute received, as of November 2026. Lose that dispute on a $48 order and $63 is gone, which by our arithmetic takes about three more sales at $20.81 to earn back.

Sales tax can become a line item

Stripe Tax Basic costs 0.5% per transaction on no-code setups, where you are registered to collect, as of November 2026. That is 24 cents here. Ask your accountant where you must register.

Ads can make a sale worthless

If you need $21 in clicks to win that order, you sold it for nothing. Measure your own cost per sale before scaling, with a tracked small budget.

The first-year bill, once the boring tools show up

A store also needs an inbox and a set of books. Google Workspace Business Starter is listed at $7 per user per month as of November 2026, so confirm the term at checkout. QuickBooks Online Simple Start lists at $38 a month for one user as of November 2026, ignoring the promotion. Its Free plan has no third-party integrations, so the moment you want orders flowing into your books, it stops being free in practice.

Year one, one person, domain and apps not included, our arithmetic on November 2026 list prices
Shopify Basic, billed yearlyDataCram lowest store
Store build$0, your weekends$2,500
Platform or hosting, 12 months$348From $660
Email, one user$84$84
QuickBooks Simple Start$456$456
Total, before any sale$888$3,700

That $888 could go lower. You could keep your books in a spreadsheet for a while, and plenty of owners do. For the longer list of what a site costs year after year, see the true cost of running a website, and for setting the overall number, the website budget guide. What the $3,700 column buys is someone else's hours and a store with your rules in it. It does not buy sales, and nobody honest can promise you that it will.

Price the platform in orders, not dollars, and most store arguments end on their own.

Run these numbers before you pay anyone, us included

  1. 1

    Write down your one most common order

    Use the real price, real materials and real packaging. A guess is fine for now, but mark it as a guess.

  2. 2

    Get a real shipping quote

    Weigh a boxed sample and price it to a far address.

  3. 3

    Subtract the card fee

    Multiply by 0.029 and add 30 cents for Stripe's standard rate as of November 2026, or use your provider's rate.

  4. 4

    Divide the monthly platform bill by what is left

    If the answer is more orders than you can realistically sell, take a cheaper door or raise the price.

  5. 5

    Start small on purpose

    If you have never sold this product online, a payment link on your existing site can test demand for the cost of a few fees.

When the numbers do justify a build, our pricing page lists stores from $2,500 and a free mockup lets you look before you spend. If what you actually need is a storefront with a few pages, the web design overview for very small companies may fit better. The small-store build page says who should skip a custom store, and a hub of pages for small operators covers the rest. Call (210) 346-0848 if you want to run your order through this with a person on the line.

Questions owner-operators ask

A Stripe payment link or embeddable buy button. Stripe describes Payment Links as a way to accept payments without writing code, on a Stripe-hosted page. You pay the per-sale fee, 2.9% plus 30 cents for domestic cards as of November 2026. It suits a few products and buyers who already trust you, and it is a poor fit for a large catalog.

Online stores start at $2,500, as a fixed quote based on what the store has to do. Hosting and maintenance starts at $55 a month. With 0% financing, 25% down, $2,500 becomes $625 down and $156.25 a month for 12 months. Card fees go to your payment provider. There is no special small-business price, and no discount.

Divide the monthly bill by what one order keeps. In our invented $48 example, an order keeps $20.81, so Shopify Basic at $29 takes two orders a month and a financed $2,500 custom store with hosting takes 11 in the first year. Your answer depends entirely on your own margin and packing costs.

Not on Stripe, in the usual case. Stripe's refund documentation says the processing fees from the original transaction are not returned, although a refund issued shortly after the charge can appear as a reversal, for which Stripe withholds no fee. Budget for refunds as a real cost, and check your own provider's rule if you use another.

Only if the price can carry it. Free shipping is a discount that happens to go to a carrier. Add the label cost to your order math, then decide whether to raise prices, set a minimum order or charge a flat rate. Test it against your actual orders, since no general answer holds for every product.

Keep reading

Free · No obligation

Send us one order and we will check the math

Tell us what you sell, what it costs you and what you think it ships for. A person at DataCram replies with the cheapest setup that fits, even when that setup does not involve hiring us.

Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)

Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.

CallGet a quote