The middle, itemized
Gray Hat SEO, Tactic by Tactic: What Google's Text Says, What It Risks and Who Pays If It Goes Wrong
Gray hat is where a tactic goes when its seller would rather not read the policy aloud. It is also where perfectly legal work gets dumped by people who never read it either. So read it. Some of the middle is forbidden, some is fine, and some is merely dull.
November 9, 2026 · 11 min read
The short answer
Gray hat SEO has no definition at Google, whose documents never use the phrase. It usually means a tactic its seller thinks might pass. Some tactics sold that way are named in Google's spam policies, some are poor practice no policy forbids, and some are plainly allowed. In nearly every case the owner's domain carries the risk.
On this page
Three piles instead of one gray smear
White, black and gray are trade slang. Across Google's spam policies, last updated August 28, 2026, and the other Google documents we searched on November 7, 2026, none of the three appears. The nearest it gets is a warning about "unethical SEOs" on its hiring page. So a claim that something is gray tells you about the seller's nerve and nothing about Google's text. Our guide to Google's rules walks through each policy. This page sorts the disputed ones.
Named in the policies
Google's text describes it as spam. Calling it gray does not move it. Here the only real question is how likely you are to be caught, which is a poor question to build a business on.
Google warns, and no spam policy lists it
Guidance discourages it as a sign of content made for search engines, or the practice is merely weak. Fair criticism, but not a violation, and anyone calling it one is overstating the case.
Google says it is allowed
Accordions, tagged paid links, an old domain used for a real new site. Competitors and nervous consultants call these shady anyway. Google's text says otherwise.
One caution keeps this from being a loophole list. Google says its policies cover common practices and that it may act against any type of spam it detects. Spam itself is defined broadly, as techniques used to deceive users or manipulate its systems into featuring content prominently. An unlisted trick is not automatically a safe one. It is also not automatically a violation, and fairness requires saying both.
Twelve tactics, set against Google's actual words
The second column paraphrases Google's spam policies, last updated August 28, 2026, unless noted. The risk column is our judgment, not a measurement. We have no figures for how often any of this is caught, and we read none from Google. "Who carries it" is also our judgment, and it names where the damage lands first.
| Tactic | What Google's text says | Risk, our judgment | Who carries it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paying for a followed link | Named: exchanging money for links. Fine if tagged sponsored or nofollow | High | Your domain, and the seller's site |
| Regular link swaps with partners | Named when excessive, or partner pages made only to cross-link. No number given. See reciprocal links | Low for a real partner, rising with habit | Both sites |
| A free product for a review with a link | Named. The FTC's Endorsement Guides also count free goods as a possible connection to disclose | Medium to high | You, and the writer who took it |
| Guest posts with keyword anchors | Named: optimized anchor text in guest posts. See the guest posting page | High at volume | Your domain, and the host |
| A network of sites sold as a "publisher partnership" | Fits the link spam definition if it exists to pass links. Creating multiple sites to hide scale is a named scaled content example | High | Every client in the network |
| Buying an expired domain | Abuse when repurposed mainly to manipulate rankings with low-value content. Fine for a new, original site, per Google on March 5, 2024 | Depends entirely on what you build | You |
| Vendor credit links across client footers | Named: widely distributed links in the footers or templates of various sites. "Widely" is not defined | Low to medium | The vendor's site, and the sites carrying the links |
| AI drafts published in bulk | Named: scaled content abuse. One checked draft is not | High at volume. AI content draws the line | Your domain |
| Near-identical city pages | Named: doorway examples include pages targeted at cities that funnel to one page. See city pages | Medium to high | Your domain |
| Scraping Google's results to check rank | Named: machine-generated traffic, also against Google's Terms of Service, unless permitted | Depends on who runs it. Ask, and use Search Console for your own site | Whoever sends the queries |
| Changing a page's date without changing it | Not a listed spam policy. Google's guidance, last updated October 5, 2026, warns against it | Low from Google. It still misleads the reader | Your credibility |
| Writing to a word count | Not a listed spam policy. Same guidance warns against it and says Google has no preferred count | Low. Mostly a waste | Your budget |

The free product row has a rule outside Google. The FTC's Endorsement Guides, 16 CFR 255.5 in the January 1, 2026 edition, say material connections can include free or discounted products, whether or not an endorsement was required. We are not lawyers, so take a question like that to your own attorney. We also did not check how any rank tracking product collects its data, so we name none. For your own site, the average position in Search Console comes from Google directly.
The words sellers lean on: excessive, primarily, widely
Read the policy and you will find soft edges on purpose. Link spam is creating links "primarily" to manipulate rankings. Link exchanges are a problem when "excessive." Footer links when "widely" distributed. Sellers point at those words and ask how many is too many. Google does not say, and it does not owe you a number, because the number would become the new floor by Friday.
This is where honesty cuts both ways. Some of these tactics may work for a while, and pretending otherwise insults anyone who has watched a competitor do it. Nothing we read claims Google catches everything on the first day. What it says about what happens later is specific. Its December 14, 2022 post says SpamBrain can detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links, and that its systems aim to nullify unnatural links at scale. Its spam updates page, last updated December 10, 2025, says that once spammy links lose their value the benefit is lost and "cannot be regained." So the honest pitch for a gray tactic is: a rental, with an unknown end date, paid for in advance.
Google also wrote on March 5, 2024 that expired domain abuse "isn't something people accidentally do." That line deserves a place on the wall. A person can break a hidden text rule by accident with a bad template. Nobody buys a defunct school's domain to host casino pages in a moment of confusion, and most of what gets sold as gray falls in that deliberate category.
A gamble is only reasonable when the person placing the bet owns the loss.
Who is holding the bag when it stops working
Look at the deal from the seller's side. The agency has many clients and collects a fee. A publisher network has many sites. Someone running affiliate pages may keep a dozen domains and treat each as disposable, and on those terms an aggressive tactic might even be a rational bet. A roofer has one domain, the name on the truck and a phone number printed on magnets. The same tactic is a different bet for that owner, and the seller is not the one making it.
- The notice comes to you. Google says it notifies owners of a manual action in the Manual actions report and message center. The action sits on your site, not on the agency's.
- The responsibility is yours in Google's words. "Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire," on the page last updated June 5, 2026.
- The cleanup is yours too. Google asks for a good-faith effort to remove links and documentation of what was done, and says most reconsideration reviews can take several days or weeks, with link cases possibly longer.
- Moving does not end it. Google's policy on circumvention says continuing to violate through new subdomains, subdirectories or sites can lead it to restrict features or remove more of a site.
- The other costs are not in the report. Staff time, the months of waiting and the pages you delayed while chasing the shortcut. Nobody invoices you for those, and they are real.
Before you agree to anything in the middle, ask three questions. Would you show the tactic to a customer? Does it still make sense with the link tagged or the page removed? And does the contract say who pays to clean up? A vendor who answers all three without flinching has either thought about it or has not read your contract. The page on hiring an SEO company has more questions, and spotting black hat work shows how to check what has been done.
Things called gray that Google says are fine
Being fair runs in this direction too. Each of these has been called shady by someone who wanted to look careful. Do not let a consultant bill you to remove them, and do not let a competitor's forum post scare you off them.
| Practice | What Google says | Where the limit is |
|---|---|---|
| Accordions, tabs and sliders | Do not violate its policies, per the August 28, 2026 page | Text truly placed to be hidden, such as white on white |
| Text only for screen readers | Same page, no violation | Stuffing keywords into it to manipulate rankings |
| Affiliate links | Generally fine to monetize with, and qualify them with rel="sponsored", per July 26, 2021 | Thin pages copied from the merchant with nothing added |
| Paid ads and sponsorships with a link | A normal part of the web's economy when tagged | An untagged link sold as a sponsorship |
| Redirects after a site move | Moving a site and consolidating pages are named as legitimate | Sending mobile users to a spam domain |
| AI as a drafting aid | Appropriate use is not against its guidelines, February 8, 2023 | Many pages generated without adding value |
| Hosting third-party content | Not inconsistent with the site reputation policy by itself | Hosting it mainly to borrow your ranking signals |
Other rulebooks apply elsewhere, and people confuse them. A keyword-stuffed business name is a matter for the Google Business Profile guidelines, which say unnecessary information in a name could result in suspension, as our page on white hat local SEO covers. Paying for a review is a Maps policy problem and potentially a federal one, as our review page sets out. Google's third-party SEO guidance, last updated June 5, 2026, offers a test for advice you read anywhere: good advice qualifies a claim as opinion, or cites official Google guidance. Apply it to ours.
Where this leaves the owner with a proposal on the desk
- 1
Name the tactic in plain words
Cross out "partnership," "placement," "authority" and "outreach." Write what happens: we pay a site, a link appears. Sort it into one of the three piles.
- 2
Find the line in the policy
Search Google's spam policies for the words that describe it. It takes a minute, and a vendor who has already done this will be glad you did.
- 3
Price the bad case
Ask what your business looks like with the site ranking lower for a few months, in calls and not in rankings. Then compare that with what the tactic might gain.
- 4
Decide who owns the downside
If it is you, and it nearly always is, you should be the one choosing the risk, in writing, with the tactic named.
Many owners will stop at step one. Some will decide a low-risk row is fine for them, and that is their call: a real partner link is not a scandal. What we would object to is anyone making that decision for you and calling it strategy. If an old tactic is already in your link report, the page on removing bad backlinks comes next.
DataCram sells the slower version, so you should expect us to prefer it. Our SEO pricing page says authority work is "earned, never bought" and describes bought links as a liability with a delay. SEO programs start from $575 a month as of November 2026, depending on complexity, setup and budget, with no long contract, and white hat link building explains what that part involves. We cannot guarantee a ranking and neither can anyone else: Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. If you want a second read on a proposal, the hub for this section and the free site audit are the low-cost places to begin. When something has already gone wrong, visibility recovery is quoted after a look at the site.
Questions owners ask about white hat SEO
No. In the Google documents we searched on November 7, 2026, including Search Essentials, the spam policies and the rater guidelines, white hat, black hat and gray hat do not appear. It is trade slang. Google's terms are spam policies, manual actions and demotion. When someone calls a tactic gray, ask which line of the policy they think it sits near.
For a while, sometimes. Nothing we read claims Google catches everything at once, and you may well see competitors rank with tactics you would avoid. What Google does say is that its systems aim to nullify unnatural links at scale, and that once spammy links stop counting, any benefit cannot be regained. So a gray result is best understood as rented, on terms you do not control.
The label does not matter, but the text does. A network of sites that exists to pass links to clients is creating links primarily to manipulate rankings, which is Google's definition of link spam, and creating multiple sites to hide scale is a named scaled content example. Calling it a publisher partnership changes the invoice and nothing else. Any site paying or being paid should tag the links.
In Google's eyes, yes. Its hiring page says you are responsible for the actions of companies you hire, and any manual action or lost ranking credit lands on your domain. Whether the agency owes you anything depends on your contract, which is a question for your own attorney. Ask now for a written list of what was done and what was paid for.
It is not among the listed spam policies. Google's helpful content guidance, last updated October 5, 2026, names changing dates to seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed as a warning sign of search-first content. If you really updated the page, a new date is honest. If you did not, you are misleading readers, which is reason enough to stop.
You can copy anything Google allows. For the rest, a competitor ranking with a tactic proves only that it has not been dealt with yet, and you cannot see its risk or its other domains. Anyone can file a search quality report, which Google says it uses to improve spam detection. Spend the time on work that holds up if you stop paying for it.
Keep reading
- Where Google draws the lineWhite Hat vs Black Hat SEO: Google's Spam Policies One by One, the Two Kinds of Penalty, and the Way BackWhite hat vs black hat SEO, settled by Google's own spam policies: all sixteen explained, manual vs algorithmic penalties, and how sites recover.
- Earned, or something elseWhite Hat Link Building: What Earns a Link, Where the Scheme Starts and What Can Honestly Be PromisedWhite hat link building explained: why a stranger links to you, where Google's link spam policy starts, what a provider can promise, and how to check it.
- Before you signHow to Hire a White Hat SEO Company: Questions That Force Evidence, Contract Terms, and Who Holds the AccountsHow to hire a white hat SEO company: nine questions that demand a document, the contract terms to insist on, and who should hold each account.
- The monthly workWhite Hat SEO Services: One Month Opened Up, Line by Line, With the Evidence Each Line LeavesWhat ethical SEO services contain in a month, what you can open and inspect, what we will not do, and our price: from $575 a month, no long contract.
- The arithmeticWhite Hat SEO Pricing: Why the Cheap Offer Is Cheap, Where the Money Goes and When to Spend NothingWhat ethical SEO costs and why: the arithmetic of the $99 backlink offer, where an honest month's money goes, a budget test, and when to spend nothing.
- Local, without the mailboxWhite Hat Local SEO: Real Addresses, Real Reviews and a Business Name Nobody StuffedWhite hat local SEO in plain terms: Google Business Profile rules field by field, honest service areas, reviews nobody arranged, and who holds the keys.
- Everything in White Hat SEOSee the section
From the Insights desk
- 10 Proven Strategies to Rank Higher in AI-Powered Search EnginesAI search algorithms prioritize user intent, context, and content relevance with unprecedented precision. Ten data-driven strategies to stay competitive.
- 7 Signs Your Website Is Quietly Losing You CustomersA website rarely fails loudly — it just quietly lets customers slip away, and you never see the ones who left. Seven signs yours is leaking, from slow mobile loads to stale listings to no conversion tracking, and the fix for each.
Get a proposal read against Google's text
Send us the proposal or the tactic you were offered. A person at DataCram will sort it into the three piles and tell you which line of which policy applies, knowing that we also sell this work.
Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)
Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.