Links in your name
Remove Bad Backlinks or Disavow Them? What Google Says, and the Common Case for Doing Neither
A tool says 412 of your links are toxic. A stranger offers to clean them up for a monthly fee. Before you pay anyone, read what the company that runs the search engine says about it, because Google's advice is far less exciting than the sales email.
November 9, 2026 · 11 min read
- # 2023 link package from a former vendor
- # removal requested twice by email, no reply
- domain:acmearticlehub.com
- https://acmeblogring.com/attic-tips-paid-post
- scraper sites nobody paid for: left out
- local paper that chose to link: left out
The short answer
Most sites should not disavow anything. Google says to use the tool only when you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links and they have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. Both must hold. Links you or your agency paid for should be removed or marked sponsored first. Random junk you never asked for can usually be ignored.
On this page
- Google's two conditions, and how few sites meet them
- The question that sorts every link: who put it there?
- Getting a paid link taken down: the awkward email
- What you give up, said plainly
- If both conditions hold: the traps inside the tool
- When a reviewer has already written to you
- When to spend nothing, and when to pay someone
Google's two conditions, and how few sites meet them
The disavow tool lets you ask Google to ignore links. Google's help page for it, read November 7, 2026, is about as discouraging as a product page can be. It calls the tool "an advanced feature" that "should only be used with caution," warns that using it incorrectly can potentially harm your site's performance, and says that in most cases Google can assess which links to trust without help, "so most sites will not need to use this tool." Now picture a sales page written by a firm that charges for it.
Then come the conditions. Google says to disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing at the site, and those links have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. Both have to hold. A few dozen ugly links fail the first. A big pile of ugly links nobody built on your behalf often fails the second. The example Google gives is bad links built by you or an SEO you hired, through paid links or other link schemes.
A Google employee added a dry note in a Bluesky post, reported by Search Engine Roundtable on January 24, 2025: his own estimate, without data at hand, was that 90%+, probably 99%+, of the web has never used the tool. That is one employee's guess and not a Google figure. He also wrote that "it's in a spammer's best interest to encourage others to spend time on it." Consider that before you buy a monthly cleanup.
The question that sorts every link: who put it there?
Forget the score and ask how the link came to exist. Our backlink audit guide sorts links into piles for a full review. For this decision a shorter frame will do, because the answer to "should I remove or disavow it" follows almost entirely from who made the link and why. The table is our reading of Google's documents, applied to situations they do not spell out one by one. It is not a Google rule.
| How the link got there | Remove? | Disavow? | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| You or your agency paid for it, and it is followed | Yes, or get it marked sponsored or nofollow | Only what cannot be removed, and only if both conditions hold | Google's link spam policy lists exchanging money, goods or services for links |
| Same, already marked sponsored or nofollow | No need | No | Google calls that a normal part of the web's economy |
| Your own guest posts with keyword-rich links | Ask for plain wording or a sponsored or nofollow attribute | Rarely | The policy names optimized anchor text in guest posts. See our guest posting page |
| Excess link swaps or partner pages you agreed to | Yes, on your side and theirs | Rarely | Excessive link exchanges are on the list; ordinary mutual links are not automatically a problem. See reciprocal links |
| A scraper or junk directory you never contacted | No | Usually no | Google says it can usually judge these without help |
| A large spammy pattern you did not build, and you are worried | Ask the site owner if you can reach one | Only if both conditions plausibly hold | See negative SEO. Google's Links report help does mention disavowing as a last resort |
| A real site that just looks old or ugly | No | No | Google warns against disavowing organic links |

Getting a paid link taken down: the awkward email
Google's instruction is plain: try removing links from the other site first, and disavow only what cannot be removed. That means writing to strangers about a thing that embarrasses both of you. The trick is to keep it short, polite and free of any accusation. Do these in order. Keep every message, because if a manual action ever comes into it, Google asks for documentation of links removed and an explanation of those that could not be.
- 1
Ask the vendor first
Whoever placed the links knows where they are and who to ask. Request the full list in writing. If they placed them through a network, they may be able to have them pulled faster than you can.
- 2
Build your list from two sources
Search Console is a sample, so add Bing or another tool. Our audit of past work covers getting the export. Open each page to confirm the link is live and check its rel attribute, because the Links report does not show it.
- 3
Find a person
Check the site's contact page, its about page or the article's author. Send one message per site, even if you have twenty links there.
- 4
Ask for either of two things
Removal, or a sponsored or nofollow attribute. The second may be easier to agree to, because the owner keeps the page. Google's link spam policy says a paid link qualified that way is not a violation.
- 5
Follow up once, then record it
Wait a couple of weeks and send one reminder. Note the date, the address and the outcome in your sheet. No reply is an outcome, and it is the honest basis for any disavow entry later.
Some sites may ask for a fee to take a link down. That is your decision; we would not make a habit of paying it, and we would record the request. There is a reason a publisher might want to cooperate: Google's December 14, 2022 announcement said SpamBrain can detect both sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links. Leave that out of your email. They will have read it, or they will not.
What you give up, said plainly
The usual objection: "Those links are the reason we rank. Remove them and we fall." Possibly. Nobody can tell you in advance, and anyone who says they can is guessing. But look at what Google has said about it. Its spam updates page, last updated December 10, 2025, says any ranking benefit from spammy links that its systems discount is lost and "cannot be regained." The December 2022 post said its algorithms and manual actions aim to nullify unnatural links at scale. So you may be protecting a benefit that has already gone.
The case for cleaning up
- Paid followed links are on Google's link spam list, and a manual action for unnatural links exists
- You control the fix now, before a reviewer sets the terms
- You stop paying rent on links you may not be getting credit for
- You can truthfully tell a buyer or partner the record is clean
The case for caution
- Rankings may slip if some of those links still count
- A disavow done wrong can potentially hurt, Google says
- Time spent on junk links is time not spent earning real ones
- Removing links you did not arrange is usually wasted effort
Our view, and it is only that: remove what was bought, leave what was not, and spend the saved time on earning links people choose to give. If you are unsure whether a tactic even counts as a problem, our gray hat page goes through the middle ground.
If both conditions hold: the traps inside the tool
Our audit guide covers how to write the file. These are the points where owners and former vendors tend to go wrong, all from Google's disavow help as read November 7, 2026. Check them in this order before you upload anything.
- You may not be able to use it at all. The tool does not support Domain properties, and only a property owner can upload a list. If you have only a Domain property, you need a URL-prefix property first. Your agency's full-user seat will not do.
- There may already be a list. Each property has one, and a new upload replaces the old one. A past agency's list disappears when you upload yours, so read it first and merge anything worth keeping.
- Http and https count separately. Each property needs its own list. If your site has moved between them, check both.
- Domains are written domain:example.com. One URL or domain per line, in a .txt file, up to 100,000 lines and 2 MB. Choose domains for networks and single URLs for one bad article on a good site.
- It will not show. Google says disavowed links keep appearing in the Links report, and it can take a few weeks for a list to be incorporated, the same for canceling one. Seeing them there does not mean the upload failed.
- Blanket uploads do not count as effort. Google's Manual actions help says blindly adding all backlinks to the disavow file will not be enough, and warns against disavowing organic links.
When a reviewer has already written to you
An "Unnatural links to your site" notice changes the job. The two conditions are no longer hypothetical, and you now have an audience. Google's Manual actions help, read November 7, 2026, asks for a good-faith effort to remove links first and for documentation of what you removed and why the rest could not be. Your email log is that documentation. Google also says link-related reconsideration requests may take longer than usual. Our page on recovering after a shortcut has the order of work, and the guide to Google's rules covers the request itself.
The opposite notice exists too. "Unnatural links from your site" means you are the seller, or someone used your site as one. Maybe an old vendor set up a "partners" page, or you accepted payment for a post years ago. Google says to remove those links or change them so they no longer pass PageRank, for example with rel="nofollow" or a more specific attribute. Its guide to qualifying links, last updated December 10, 2025, says rel="sponsored" is preferred for paid placements. Our nofollow guide explains the differences.
When to spend nothing, and when to pay someone
Spend nothing if the Manual actions report is clean, you never bought a link, and the only reason you are here is a red number from a tool or a stranger's email. That describes a lot of readers. Close the tab and go earn something. Google's page on hiring an SEO, last updated June 5, 2026, tells you to be wary of firms that email out of the blue, and a surprise toxic link report is a fine example of the type.
It is worth paying when you have a manual action, when a past agency built links at scale and you cannot find a list, or when the link export runs to more rows than you will ever read. DataCram's link cleanup has no published price, so it is quoted after a look at the site. If it is part of a recovery, SEO visibility recovery starts with diagnosis. Ongoing white hat work runs from $575 a month, depending on complexity, setup and budget, with no long contract. We sell this work, so you should check our reasoning against Google's pages. Our website audit is free and a fair first look.
Questions owners ask about white hat SEO
Not because a tool flagged them. Google says to disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links and they have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. A toxic score is one vendor's model, and Google says third-party tools have no access to its internal ranking data. Find out how those links came to exist first.
Find a real contact on the site and send a short, polite note naming the page, the link and what you would like: removal, or a sponsored or nofollow attribute. Ask the vendor who placed it first, since it may be quicker. Send one reminder, then record the outcome. Google asks for that kind of documentation if a manual action is involved.
It might. Nobody can say in advance. If Google's systems have already discounted those links, there is little left to lose, and its spam updates page says that the benefit is gone and cannot be regained. If some still count, you may slip. Weigh that against carrying a pattern that matches its link spam policy, on a domain that only you can pay for.
Probably because of the property type or your role. Google says the tool does not support Domain properties and that only a property owner can upload a list. Verify a URL-prefix property for the version of the site you serve, as an owner, and try again. If your agency set up the account, you may need to verify yourself first.
Usually no. Google's second condition allows for links that "likely will" cause a manual action, so there is room for a preventive list if you know a past vendor built a large number of paid links. Even then, try removal first. If the links are just junk nobody arranged, Google says it can generally judge them without your help.
Google warns against disavowing organic links and says incorrect use can potentially harm a site's performance. You can cancel or replace the list. Google says it can take a few weeks for a list to be incorporated, and the same for canceling. So keep a dated copy of each file and a note of why each entry is there.
Keep reading
- Link cleanup, calmlyBacklink Audit: How to Check Who Links to You, Step by Step, and Why You Probably Will Not Need to DisavowAudit backlinks with Search Console's Links report and a third-party tool, sort them into four piles, and learn when Google's disavow tool is warranted.
- After the shortcutRecover From Black Hat SEO: The Order of Work After a Shortcut Goes WrongHow to recover from black hat SEO or a Google penalty: what to stop first, how to tell manual from automated, what to undo, and Google's own time language.
- Can a rival hurt youNegative SEO: Can Competitors Hurt Your Rankings? What Google Actually Says, and What Is Worth WatchingCan a competitor hurt your rankings? What Google says about negative SEO, word for word and with its limits, the real attacks, and what to watch monthly.
- The monthly workWhite Hat SEO Services: One Month Opened Up, Line by Line, With the Evidence Each Line LeavesWhat ethical SEO services contain in a month, what you can open and inspect, what we will not do, and our price: from $575 a month, no long contract.
- The arithmeticWhite Hat SEO Pricing: Why the Cheap Offer Is Cheap, Where the Money Goes and When to Spend NothingWhat ethical SEO costs and why: the arithmetic of the $99 backlink offer, where an honest month's money goes, a budget test, and when to spend nothing.
- Earned, or something elseWhite Hat Link Building: What Earns a Link, Where the Scheme Starts and What Can Honestly Be PromisedWhite hat link building explained: why a stranger links to you, where Google's link spam policy starts, what a provider can promise, and how to check it.
- Everything in White Hat SEOSee the section
From the Insights desk
- We Added llms.txt to This Site. It Probably Does Nothing Yet.This site has an llms.txt. It is auto-generated, it costs nothing to maintain, and there is no public evidence that any major AI system reads it. Here is why we added it anyway — and how to spot the moment 'might help' becomes a line item.
- What a Fast Website Is Actually Worth — in DollarsSpeed is a sales number wearing an engineer's costume. Every second your site makes a visitor wait, a share of them leave — customers you already paid to attract. How a fast website turns into dollars, with the math for your own traffic.
Find out if your links are really the problem
Tell us your site and what you know about past link work. A person at DataCram replies with whether we think this needs cleanup at all, or says leave it alone.
Which of these sounds like you? (pick any)
Rather talk now? Call (210) 346-0848.